Why Am I Not Losing Weight on My Low Calorie Diet?

Low-calorie meal Diet portion control Weight loss food Healthy eating habits Low-calorie breakfast Satisfying small portion Balanced breakfast option Nutritious oatmeal snack

Choosing the lowest calorie option seems to make perfect sense if you’re trying to lose weight. It feels like you’re in complete control of how much you eat and how much weight you lose. 

But, is that really the case? Well, the research suggests otherwise. 

Why Low Calorie Choices SOMETIMES Backfire

You see, a study published in the journal Appetite back in 2011 found something interesting: when people constantly pick low calorie foods, they end up feeling hungrier, less satisfied, and more likely to overeat later. In this study, participants were given the same milkshake with the same amount of calories. But, half were told it was "indulgent" and high in calories. The other half were told it was a "sensible" low calorie shake. 

The results? Those who thought they had the high calorie shake experienced a bigger drop in ghrelin, the hormone that signals hunger. That is, they felt less hungry afterwards. Those who thought they had the “sensible” low calorie shake did not have any change in ghrelin, even though both shakes had the same number of calories!

This reveals an important truth: always focusing on calories may leave you less satisfied, feeling more deprived and more likely to overeat later. In the most roundabout redundant way, it really can set you up for failure.

The Danger of Restricting Too Much

When you restrict food (think cutting out carbs, dwindling down portion sizes, or choosing low calorie meals) your body and mind often respond with a jump in hunger and cravings. This is a natural, evolutionary response to “scarcity”. The more something feels scarce or “off limits”, the more likely humans are to hoard and collect more of it. A bit like the toilet paper panic-buying we all did during the first COVID-19 lockdown.

Over time you may find yourself in a cycle of under-eating, feeling unsatisfied, and then overeating, or even binge eating (read more about Binge Eating Disorder here). Cue feeling guilty, defeated and ashamed.

Why Satisfaction Matters

The key takeaway here is that satisfaction matters. When you allow yourself to enjoy what you eat, whether it’s the taste, texture, or the experience of eating, your body responds with greater feelings of fullness. The more satisfied you feel after eating, the less likely you are to overeat or snack later. Cue feeling calm.

This doesn’t mean abandoning healthy eating, but rather finding a balance. You want to include foods that not only fuel your body but also bring enjoyment.

What a Dietitian Can Help With

If you struggle with balancing satisfaction and healthy eating, a Dietitian is a great resource. Across our team of Dietitians, we specialise in the intersection of nutrition and psychology. We help you reflect on your eating habits and explore if restrictive thoughts or behaviors are fueling exhausting cycles of overeating. By understanding your unique relationship with food, we work with you to find strategies that give you clarity and leave you feeling confident in reaching your health goals.

The Bottom Line

Next time you find yourself reaching for the lowest calorie option, ask yourself “is this going to leave me satisfied?”.

If you're feeling stuck with how to balance satisfaction and nourishment, book an appointment with one of our Dietitians. We’re here to guide you toward eating habits that work for your lifestyle and long-term health goals.

 

HUNGRY FOR MORE? CHECK OUT OUR LIBRARY OF ARTICLES AND RECIPES WRITTEN BY OUR DIETITIANS:

RECIPES & ARTICLES
Tired of overeating? Stop diet struggles with this nutrition hack.
Tired of overeating? Stop diet struggles with this nutrition hack.

It’s easy to think the best diet hack is to eat more or less of “xyz”. While yes, it’s true, changing what you eat will impact your health... this isn’t the secret. Reducing decision fatigue is. Life is packed with decisions, and come mealtimes, your brain is too tired to figure out what to eat. That’s normal. But the result? You end up ordering takeout or grabbing a quick (and often less nutritious) snack. So, here's what to do instead.

Fancy a new breakfast idea? Here are 3 that take less than 10 minutes
Fancy a new breakfast idea? Here are 3 that take less than 10 minutes

If your mornings are a chaotic scramble, and your go-to breakfast is a piece of toast (which, deep down, you know leaves you hungry by mid-morning), you’re not alone. The reality is, trying to find time to whip up a nourishing breakfast is overwhelming. But, if you’re battling energy crashes, cravings, or a constant snack hunt come 3pm, your breakfast needs a rejig. Stat.

Why Am I Not Losing Weight on My Low Calorie Diet?
Why Am I Not Losing Weight on My Low Calorie Diet?

Choosing the lowest calorie option makes perfect sense if you’re trying to lose weight. Eating low calorie foods feels like you’re in complete control of how much you eat and how much weight you lose. But is that really the case? Well, the research suggests otherwise. Always focusing on calories may leave you less satisfied, feeling more deprived and more likely to overeat later.

How to Stop Afternoon Cravings: 3 Things to Avoid and 4 Things to Consider
How to Stop Afternoon Cravings: 3 Things to Avoid and 4 Things to Consider

Afternoon cravings can leave you feeling frustrated and defeated. You’re not alone in dealing with them - the afternoon “downfall” is something many of us battle. But did you know there are a few common mistakes that can make those cravings even worse? Here’s what you should avoid, as well as some things to consider, if you’re tired of struggling with the afternoon snack-attack stress.

Chimichurri Sauce Recipe
Chimichurri Sauce Recipe

Yes, Chimichurri is famous for taking steak to a whole new level of flavour. But it really shouldn’t be limited to livening up meat. Spoon this vibrant sauce over chicken, fish, tofu, roasted vegetables and salads, or stir through pasta, rice and greek yoghurt for a creamy spin. The best part? It’s packed with polyphenols. These are potent antioxidants and prebiotics linked with reduced inflammation, improved gut microbiome diversity, cardiovascular health, better blood sugar balance and more.

Does Fruit Have Too Much Sugar? Here’s the Truth
Does Fruit Have Too Much Sugar? Here’s the Truth

Sugar is a hot topic. It seems like everyone is trying to cut it out of their diet, and fruit often gets caught in the crossfire. So, does fruit really have too much sugar?

Four clever hacks to boost your iron absorption
Four clever hacks to boost your iron absorption

Iron deficiency is one of the most common deficiencies worldwide. Truly getting enough iron into your diet requires quite some planning. From understanding the different forms of iron, to combining food sources that improve absorption and avoiding foods that block absorption, it becomes very overwhelming. So, here are four unexpected hacks to help boost your iron.

A Versatile Vegetable Soup (Winter Salad)
A Versatile Vegetable Soup (Winter Salad)

Our warming Vegetable Soup is the ultimate "Winter salad" that makes getting your daily dose of vegetables during the colder months a breeze. Packed with a comforting medley of vegetables, this soup is rich in immune-supporting vitamins, antioxidants and gut-friendly fibre. There’s no better way to nourish your health in Winter than this comforting soup.

Six pantry staples every time-poor person needs to manage iron deficiency
Six pantry staples every time-poor person needs to manage iron deficiency

So, you have low iron but, you’re time poor (who isn’t?). This one’s for you. Between remembering to take your iron supplement, dealing with fatigue, and juggling life, it’s a struggle to stay on top of eating enough iron. To help out, here are six pantry staples you should always have on hand to stay on top of managing iron levels when you have little to no time.

Spinach and Red Lentil Dahl
Spinach and Red Lentil Dahl

This Spinach and Red Lentil Dahl recipe ticks all the boxes: easy-to-follow, hearty, satisfying, comforting and nourishing. Lentils are an excellent source of plant-based protein and soluble fibre, brilliant for your best gut health yet and keeping your cholesterol in check. Make in bulk and serve with a scoop of creamy tangy Greek yoghurt to boost protein.

What Most People Don't Realise Impacts the Number on the Scale
What Most People Don't Realise Impacts the Number on the Scale

Stepping on the scale. It really is a source of anxiety and confusion for many of us. And, it’s easy to become fixated on the number staring back at you. But did you know that there are many factors that can make this number fluctuate up and down, beyond just your body mass? Here are 15 (of many!) factors and why it’s important to understand these.

An Overlooked Cause of IBS: Eating Disorders
An Overlooked Cause of IBS: Eating Disorders

Turns out, there is a clear link between eating disorders (or disordered eating) and gut symptoms. Think bloating, pain, gas, diarrhoea, constipation and IBS. It’s complex, multifaceted and… far too often overlooked.  It’s also two-way. Eating disorders can cause gut symptoms and vice versa. But understanding what’s going on and how a Dietitian fits in will help you identify the best starting point to tackling your health goal.

Gut-Healthy Mediterranean Frittata
Gut-Healthy Mediterranean Frittata

Say hello to our Mediterranean Frittata. It’s a slow morning breakfast, a meal prep veg-packed lunch (nope, not another salad), and an easy dinner that feels special with shockingly little effort. And, its gut-loving. Because we stirred and sauteed some of our favourite prebiotic foods into this recipe.

Michelle Theodosi